The Gmail Warning Banner Explained: What It Really Means and How to Avoid It

Ese Taverho
May 7, 2025
If your cold emails are showing Gmail warning banners, you're not just facing a cosmetic issue — you're dealing with a reputation problem. These alerts mean Gmail has flagged your message as suspicious, spammy, or outright unsafe.
But here's the thing: not all Gmail warnings are the same. And if you're serious about inbox placement, replies, and deliverability — you need to understand what each warning means, why it happens, and how to fix it.
In this guide, we’ll break down the most common Gmail spam warning banners, explain how to test and diagnose them, and provide detailed steps to resolve them.
What Are Gmail Warning Banners?
Gmail places visual alerts either:
Inside the Spam folder, OR
Inside the Primary/Promotions inbox (in some cases)
These alerts act as automated red flags to warn users that your message may be risky or irrelevant.
Here are the most common banners Gmail uses:
1. “Why is this message in Spam? It’s similar to messages that were identified as spam in the past.”

Translation: Gmail’s algorithms have seen content like this before — and it triggered high spam complaints or low engagement.
Common Causes:
Recycled or templated cold email copy
Generic lead scraping tools
Spam trigger phrases (e.g. “FREE,” “Act Now,” “Only 2 Spots Left”)
Bad sending patterns (new domain, high volume)
How to Fix It:
Rewrite your email to feel human, custom, and value-driven.
Remove spammy phrases. Use tools like spam test.
Avoid clickbait subject lines. Test personalization instead.
Run a placement test to see how copy tweaks affect inbox vs. spam placement.
Lower your volume temporarily and warm up gradually.
2. “This message seems dangerous. It might be a scam.”

Translation: Gmail flagged this as a phishing or spoofing risk.
Common Causes:
You're using a deceptive “From” name or address
The Return-Path domain doesn't match the sender
Links point to flagged or misleading domains
How to Fix It:
Run an authentication audit with tools like Google Postmaster, MXToolbox, or DMARCian.
Ensure SPF, DKIM, and DMARC are all:
Properly configured
Aligned with your subdomain
Using strict alignment settings
Fix any Return-Path mismatches.
Remove link shorteners (Bitly, TinyURL = 🚫).
3. “Images in this message are hidden. This message might be suspicious or spam.”

Translation: Gmail blocked the pixel or image preview because it thinks this email is spammy or suspicious.
Common Causes:
Use of invisible tracking pixels
Email comes from an unknown or low-trust sender
High image-to-text ratio
Why It Matters:
Your open tracking is now broken.
The user sees a visual alert inside the inbox — not just spam folder.
How to Fix It:
Stop using open tracking in cold emails. It’s outdated and risky.
Send plain text versions without images.
Use reply rate, not opens, to track performance.
Improve your sender reputation before scaling again.
How to Monitor Gmail Banner Warnings
Most cold email tools only tell you if an email was delivered — not where it landed or what warning it triggered. Check out the difference between deliverability and delivered here.
Here’s how to test Gmail banner behaviour:
Create a group of seed inboxes (Gmail, Outlook, Yahoo, etc.)
Send from your actual cold email setup to your seed inboxes.
Log what you see:
Inbox tab (Primary, Promotions)?
Spam folder? Any banner?
Are images hidden?
Use tools like:
Google Postmaster Tools (domain health)
GlockApps or Folderly (placement + banner diagnostics)
Summary: The Banners Are Telling You the Truth
Each Gmail warning is a diagnostic tool. Treat it like a feedback loop — not a dead end.
Warning Type | Root Cause | Solution Summary |
“Similar to spam” | Reused/spammy content | Rewrite message, remove triggers |
“Seems dangerous” | Auth failure / spoofing | Fix SPF/DKIM/DMARC + headers |
“Images hidden” | Pixel abuse / low trust | Stop tracking, go plain text |
“Claims to be from you” | Self-test or spoof risk | Test externally, fix Return-Path |
“Marked as spam” | Complaints | Clean list, improve relevance |
Don’t Guess — Diagnose and Solve
If you’re seeing Gmail warnings, your domain isn’t doomed — but it is under watch. These alerts are your early warning system.
Get seen. Get replies. Not warnings.
Convinced? Elevate Your Email Strategy!
Related posts
The Demise of Email Open Tracking: Navigating Gmail's 2024 Policy Changes, in 2025
Gmail's 2024 policy shift has disrupted traditional email tracking, but are your email strategies still stuck in the past? Discover how to adapt your approach in 2025 with targeted tips for marketing and cold outreach, boost engagement, protect your sender reputation, and thrive in the evolving inbox landscape.

Ese Taverho
How Failed SPF and DKIM Break Your Cold Outreach (And How to Fix It Fast)
In this guide, you’ll learn exactly what SPF and DKIM do, why missing or broken records tank your deliverability, and step-by-step instructions to fix them in minutes. Say goodbye to unopened campaigns and hello to inbox placement—so your next cold email actually gets read.

Ese Taverho
Deliverability vs Delivered: Why Your 98% ‘Success Rate’ Might Be Lying
If your email tool is bragging about a 98% delivery rate, hold the celebration — because that number doesn’t mean what you think it does. Most email platforms are only measuring delivery, not deliverability. And there's a big difference.

Ese Taverho